Customers who want to reduce the price after the job
Leon Silcott
When a customer asks for a lower price, ask which part of the bill they dispute. Separate unfinished work, scope questions and requests for a discount.
“You'll knock something off, won't you?” can mean several different things. There may be a snag you have not seen, an extra they did not agree, or a request for a goodwill discount. Those need different conversations. Start by finding out which one you are having.
This is a practical way to organise the discussion. It does not decide either person's legal rights or turn your record into a ruling on what must be paid.
Ask for the specific concern
Reply without agreeing to a reduction or dismissing the customer:
“Please tell me which work or invoice line you're concerned about, and what you think needs changing. If it's a problem with the finish, a photo and a suitable time to look at it would help.”
Avoid asking “what's your problem?” or sending a long defence of the entire job. You need the disputed detail first. Keep the original invoice, accepted scope, photographs and messages together before you reply further.
Three different conversations
A possible defect or unfinished item. Check it against the work you agreed. Arrange a review and record what you find. You may need trade-specific or professional advice if safety or responsibility is unclear. Do not label the customer's concern a discount tactic before examining it.
A disputed extra. Look for the description, price and acceptance before the work happened. A photo showing that the extra exists is not proof that the customer agreed to pay for it. If the record is missing, acknowledge that gap plainly.
A discretionary discount request. If the customer accepts the work and price but asks for less, you can discuss whether you want to make a commercial concession. Keep the requested reduction distinct from a claim that something is wrong.
A hypothetical £640 job
A joiner, Dev, installs shelving for a fixed £640. The customer offers £580, saying one shelf is uneven and the price feels high. Dev separates the two points:
“Let's look at the uneven shelf first. Please show me which one you mean and I'll arrange a check. The £640 was the accepted price for the shelving. Your request for a £60 discount is a separate point, which I'll consider after we've checked the finish.”
If inspection confirms an adjustment is needed, Dev writes down the work and the proposed visit. He does not promise that one visit settles every issue. If the customer is simply asking for a lower price, he can say:
“I've reviewed the agreed scope and the completed work. I'm not proposing a discount, but please send any specific unfinished item you want me to inspect.”
Both replies leave room for facts the first message did not contain.
If you decide to make a concession
Describe the amount and reason accurately in your invoicing and accounting records. Do not call a £60 concession a £60 payment: no money has arrived. Keep any credit or revised invoice reference beside the original so you can explain the final calculation later.
AsAgreed is not an accounting credit-note system. Once a new payment report or receipt exists, scope and price revisions are unavailable on that agreement. Do not record invented receipts to force its displayed balance to match a concession. Preserve the real history and use your normal records to document the adjustment and any resulting discrepancy.
Where the agreement has no such payment activity, a proposed revision still needs explicit acceptance. Until then, the original accepted terms remain in place. A private decision to offer a reduction is different from a revised price both people have accepted.
Keep reminders accurate while you investigate
Do not send a message saying “you have raised no concerns” after receiving photographs of a snag. Record the concern and tell the customer when you will respond. If some parts are clear and others disputed, show that distinction in the correspondence; do not invent a settlement or payment date on their behalf.
A suitable note is:
“I've received your concern about the shelf and will reply after the visit on Thursday. The invoice remains in our records. I'll set out any agreed adjustment in writing after we've checked the work.”
A better handover record next time
Before leaving a job, compare the completed work with the accepted list. Note remaining items, changes, customer questions and the next contact date. That creates a useful starting point if the bill is questioned later.
The tradespeople page shows scope, price and payments together. Keep this dispute with its existing records; for the next job, write a clear scope and price before starting.