Extra work discovered mid-job: get agreement before you order parts or spend more time
Leon Silcott
An unexpected fault needs a customer decision. Explain the finding, proposed work, revised price and timing before ordering extra parts or adding labour.
A vehicle is on the ramp. The booked job has exposed another problem, and the technician knows what they would recommend. Reception needs to contact the customer while the workshop decides what can continue. This is the point where a clear authorisation record matters: the finding, the recommendation and the permission to spend are three different things.
This guide is about communication and records for independent garages. Technical safety decisions still need appropriate expertise. It does not tell you what work is legally authorised or what rights you have over a vehicle.
Confirm the original authority first
Open the accepted job description. Was the customer booking a service, authorising a defined repair or paying for diagnosis? What exclusions or spending boundaries were actually discussed? Do not rely on a technician's internal job notes as proof that the customer saw the same scope.
Suppose the original job is front brake work at an estimate of £280 to £340. That is the starting range, not permission to add any fault found nearby. Record the discovery against the correct vehicle and job reference so it does not become an unexplained part number later.
Ask who can approve the change. The driver who dropped off a company vehicle may need a fleet contact to decide. A relative answering a phone may be able to pass on a message without being authorised to accept the cost.
Describe the finding in ordinary language
The customer needs enough explanation to make a decision, not a transcript of the workshop conversation. Describe what was found, why it matters to the proposed repair and what you recommend. Distinguish an observation from a diagnosis that still needs investigation.
A photo can help show the component in question, provided it is relevant and handled appropriately. It does not replace a price proposal or count as approval. “We sent pictures” is not an answer to “what did I agree to pay?”
Avoid telling the customer an item is optional or urgent unless that reflects a properly supported technical judgement. If you cannot explain the finding confidently yet, say what further assessment is needed and discuss any associated scope or cost before proceeding.
Give the whole price picture
For a hypothetical brake job, a seized caliper adds to the work. A useful proposal might say:
“During the agreed front-brake work we found a seized caliper. We propose replacing it as well. The original estimate was £280 to £340. With the caliper included, the revised estimate is £400 to £480, made up of £120 to £160 labour and £280 to £320 parts. We expect collection to move from this afternoon to tomorrow, subject to the part arriving. Please review the revised scope and estimate before we order the part.”
The numbers are illustrative, not typical prices. The structure is what matters: original position, new work, revised range and timing. Do not give only the extra part price if labour or other costs also change.
Be explicit about tax and other charges in your normal quotation process. Do not leave a customer to discover at collection that the total they accepted excluded an amount they reasonably expected to see.
Ask a question with real choices
“Okay?” at the end of a technical explanation is vague. Ask whether the customer wants to accept the proposed work and price basis, needs further explanation or wishes to discuss a different option.
If the customer declines, record the decision and discuss the appropriate next steps for the vehicle. Use the relevant professional judgement about vehicle safety and workshop responsibilities. Do not assume every vehicle can simply be driven away or left untouched after work is declined.
If they want time to decide, agree when you will next speak and explain any genuine effect on parts availability or the collection estimate. Avoid a pressure deadline invented solely to get an answer.
Keep the workshop and reception aligned
A customer acceptance should identify the proposal it relates to. “Go ahead” is hard to interpret if the preceding call mentioned three possible jobs and two different prices. Summarise the selected option and ensure the record is available to the person ordering the part.
A practical handoff contains the job reference, accepted work, accepted price basis, acceptance time, contact and remaining questions. Staff should not have to infer approval from the fact that a part has already been ordered.
Choose an internal check before purchase or additional work begins: can the person proceeding locate the relevant customer decision? This is a workflow choice you implement in the business. AsAgreed does not automatically supervise parts ordering or enforce your workshop approvals.
Use revisions before payment activity
AsAgreed supports a complete proposed revised scope and price before any new payment report or receipt. The accepted original terms stay in place until the customer explicitly accepts the new version. Opening the link or viewing a photo is not acceptance.
Once a new payment report or receipt exists, scope and price revisions are unavailable on that agreement. Later extra work needs a fresh agreement. This is worth planning around for jobs that take an early payment or deposit.
For example, if the original service already has a newly confirmed payment, create a separate proposal for the caliper work rather than trying to rewrite the paid service agreement. Explain how the records relate and avoid duplicating charges from the original job.
Create a separate proposal for the later repair
An accepted estimate still needs a final price
After the work, suppose the final figure is £460 within the accepted £400 to £480 estimate. In AsAgreed, the customer accepts that final price separately before a payable balance is shown and new payments can be recorded.
Do not say that being within the range makes the £460 automatically accepted. The range sets out the estimate; the final figure is another decision. Present the final scope and calculation clearly so the customer can see how the total arose.
Likewise, completing the work or marking a deliverable complete does not approve the bill. Keep the work report and final-price request connected but distinct. If the final number differs from what was discussed, explain the reason rather than relying on the customer to notice it in an invoice.
If the customer cannot be reached
Check that you have used the agreed contact route and reached the right person. Leave a concise message identifying the job and asking them to contact you about an additional-work proposal. Avoid putting unnecessary personal or technical detail into a message another person might receive.
Record the attempted contact and what is waiting for a decision. Do not use silence as consent to an extra charge. Discuss internally what can continue within the existing scope and what requires a decision or appropriate technical precautions.
Send an update if the expected collection time changes. A customer travelling to the garage based on the original time needs a practical update, even if you are still waiting for approval. “We are awaiting your decision on the proposed additional work” is more informative than “not ready yet”.
If you ordered before approval
Do not repair the missing authorisation by writing “customer agreed” after the fact. Preserve the actual sequence and tell the relevant manager what happened. Review what the customer was told, what costs were committed and what needs to be discussed now.
A candid opening might be: “We ordered the part before completing the approval conversation. I want to explain the position and discuss the proposed work rather than assume you accepted it.” The appropriate resolution depends on the facts and your professional advice.
Keep this separate from the routine process for the next job. A mistake should lead to a useful check at the authorisation point, not a new blanket claim that every customer must pay for any part the garage has ordered.
Complete the handover without losing the history
At collection, show the accepted original work, the accepted additional work, the separately accepted final figure where relevant and payments received. The customer should not have to reverse-engineer the bill from part codes.
If £160 is paid externally against the £460 final price, the customer can report it and the garage confirms receipt after checking. Only that confirmation reduces the confirmed balance to £300. A promise to pay the remaining amount later does not count as a report of money sent.
Keep your invoice and payment processor records alongside this shared view. AsAgreed does not take the payment or reconcile a bank account automatically.
Recheck a proposal if the part changes
A customer may accept one proposed component, then a supplier offers a different option. Compare it with what was accepted before proceeding. A different brand, specification, price or delivery date may need another discussion rather than an assumption that the first decision covers it.
Explain what changed and why, using the information you can support. Do not describe a substitute as equivalent unless that judgement is properly established. Keep the revised proposal connected to the original job reference and check whether payment activity means it needs a fresh agreement. The workshop should work from the actual accepted option, rather than whichever supplier message was most recent.
A repeatable authorisation check
Before ordering extra parts or starting additional labour, ask: have we described the finding, proposed the work, shown the full price basis, explained the timing and located explicit acceptance? If any answer is missing, identify the actual gap before the job moves on.
The garage overview follows an estimate through revised scope and separately approved final price. For your next booking, connect the shared scope to your workshop authorisation process, then send the link yourself.