Extra work on site: how to agree it before you do it
Leon Silcott
Extra work on site needs a clear proposal before you start. Describe the addition, price and date effect, then ask the customer for an explicit decision.
The customer points at an unfinished corner and asks whether you can sort that as well. You may be able to do it while you are there, but proximity is not a price agreement. First check what the original job included and what the new request would change.
This guide covers the practical sequence for an ordinary proposed extra. It is not technical advice for an emergency or a statement about legal rights to payment. If you find a hazard or situation requiring immediate professional action, use the appropriate expertise and procedures to decide the safe next step.
Step 1: compare the request with the accepted scope
Open the work list before deciding the item is extra. A customer might be asking for a genuinely new task, drawing attention to something you missed or clarifying a vague part of the original description.
If the original scope says “fit the kitchen units and finish around the pipework”, boxing in a pipe may not be as clearly excluded as you remember. Your internal cost sheet does not establish what the customer saw. Read the actual proposal and discuss uncertainty honestly.
A useful holding reply is:
“I'll check that against the agreed list and work out what it involves. If it's additional work, I'll send the description, price and timing before we decide whether to go ahead.”
That acknowledges the request without promising a free addition or a new charge before you understand it.
Step 2: define the work before the figure
Name the location, quantity, materials and finish relevant to the request. “Make good that bit” is too open if one person expects a boxed panel and the other expects decoration across a whole wall.
Ask any question that affects the price or schedule. Does the work need another trade, a return visit or a material the customer must choose? Are there dependencies on the existing job? Do you need further assessment before you can offer a sensible figure?
If you cannot price it yet, say what is missing and when you expect to return with a proposal. Avoid guessing a small number to keep the conversation comfortable, then enlarging it once work has started.
Step 3: show the addition and the total
For a hypothetical kitchen installation, Sam has agreed a fixed £4,200. The customer requests three possible additions: moving a socket at £120, a cabinet fill-in panel at £85 and boxing around a pipe at £150.
If all three are accepted, they add £355, giving £4,555 in total. Show both the individual prices and the resulting total so the customer does not need to reconstruct it from separate messages.
The examples are invented, not typical prices or advice about who is qualified to undertake a particular task. Sam should only propose work within the appropriate competence and arrangements, including any necessary involvement from other professionals.
Step 4: explain timing and dependencies
A small addition can change the order of the job. A panel may need ordering, or boxing may need to happen before another finish. Describe the actual effect rather than promising “no change” because you have not checked yet.
A proposed addition might say:
“The pipe boxing is £150 fixed for the section shown in the photo, with the finish described above. It adds a return visit next Tuesday. The original kitchen installation remains £4,200; if you choose this addition alone, the combined work is £4,350. Please review the proposal before I start the boxing.”
If a supplier date is uncertain, identify it as an estimate and say when you will update the customer. Do not make a delivery promise based only on hoped-for availability.
Step 5: obtain the decision before proceeding
Ask the customer to accept, decline or request clarification on the actual proposal. A conversation about the idea is different from agreement to its price and scope. Silence, a viewed message or a nod from someone not authorised to decide should not be treated as acceptance.
In AsAgreed, before any new payment report or receipt, you can propose a complete revised scope and price. The currently accepted terms remain until the customer explicitly accepts the new version. Opening the shared link is not acceptance.
Your project plan should reflect that distinction. Do not order the additional work into the schedule as though it is already agreed while the proposal is still pending.
Know when you need a fresh agreement
Once a new payment report or receipt exists on an AsAgreed agreement, further scope and price revisions are unavailable. Later extras require a fresh agreement. This matters for site work where an early payment is part of the arrangement.
If Sam already has a new payment report on the £4,200 kitchen job, the later £150 boxing proposal needs a separate agreement. The original job and its remaining balance stay intact. The new record should make clear that it covers the additional boxing, rather than charging for the whole installation again.
Money recorded as paid before creating the agreement is a historical starting record, distinct from new payment activity. Check the agreement's actual state rather than relying on a casual description such as “deposit taken”.
If new payment activity already prevents a revision, describe the later extra in a fresh agreement and leave the original job intact.
Create a separate record for the later extra
If the customer says they thought it was included
Ask what led to that understanding and revisit the relevant scope line. If the wording is clear, show it politely. If it is not clear, acknowledge the gap before discussing a resolution.
“I understood the original list to cover the units and exclude the pipe boxing. Let's look at the wording together. If we read it differently, we need to resolve that before treating the £150 as a new charge.”
Avoid promising that a written scope removes every argument. Its practical value is that both people can examine the same words and proposed decision.
If the customer declines
Record that the proposed extra is not proceeding, then confirm the effect on the existing work. If the original job can continue unchanged, say so. If the decision affects a practical dependency, explain that and discuss the next step.
Do not use a declined option later as an invoice line. Keep proposed and accepted totals distinct in your records. A customer should not have to remember which of several prices in a thread was the one they accepted.
For a technical or safety concern, obtain the appropriate professional judgement about what can continue. Do not assume a declined proposal means every condition can safely be left unchanged.
If the customer is unreachable
Use the agreed contact route and ask for a response about the specific proposal. Note the attempt, then decide what can appropriately continue within the accepted scope and what must wait for the decision.
A useful update is:
“I haven't had a decision on the additional panel at £85. It isn't included in the accepted work, so I won't proceed with it on the basis of silence. Please reply by Thursday if you want to discuss adding it; after that I will need to check the return-visit availability.”
Use a genuine planning date, not invented urgency. Do not claim an emergency exception automatically makes an unagreed charge payable. If immediate action is needed, document the facts and seek the appropriate technical and professional guidance.
If the work happened before the price conversation
Keep the record honest. Do not write “agreed on site” if you cannot establish what was agreed. Describe the work, the missing price discussion and the customer's understanding. Discuss the position rather than hiding the item inside the final total.
A candid opening might be: “I completed the additional panel before we confirmed its price. I want to explain the work and discuss the charge rather than assume you accepted a figure we had not settled.” The right resolution depends on the actual circumstances.
Afterwards, add a check at the point where extras enter your schedule. The aim is to locate a proposal and decision before the work starts, not to create an impressive variation log after the job ends.
Keep payments distinct from approvals
A customer saying they will transfer money on Friday has made a plan, not a report of money sent. Payments happen outside AsAgreed. They can report an actual payment, and you confirm receipt after checking it arrived. Only confirmation reduces the confirmed balance.
Do not treat a receipt as approval for unrelated new work. Likewise, marking a deliverable complete does not establish the final price of an estimate. In AsAgreed, an estimated job requires separate acceptance of the final price before a payable balance appears.
Tell the person doing the work
If another member of your team will carry out the extra, give them the accepted description and any limits. A price approval passed verbally through several people can lose the detail about the chosen material or finish.
Ask the person scheduling the task to check the relevant decision before allocating it. This is your team's process; the shared agreement does not automatically manage staff or prevent someone starting. If the customer changes the request again, return to the proposal rather than treating the earlier approval as permission for any version of the task.
Close with a checkable handover
At the end, list the original work, accepted extras, declined proposals and payment position. Keep the invoice and shared record understandable together. If there is still an open question, name it and the next action rather than presenting the whole job as settled.
The tradespeople overview shows the work-and-price record beside payments. For your next job, start with the real scope and explain how any later extra will be proposed.