Late payment and unagreed extras: a practical record for tradespeople
Leon Silcott
Late payment and unagreed extras need separate records. Check the accepted work, proposed additions and confirmed receipts before discussing the balance.
The final invoice says one number. The customer remembers another. A payment has arrived, but nobody is sure whether it was intended to cover the original work or the disputed extra. Sending the same total again does not answer any of those questions.
This guide is about rebuilding a practical job record when both scope and payment have become tangled. It is not a shortcut to proving that every item you carried out was authorised. The point is to show what you can establish, what remains uncertain and what needs a new conversation.
Build three lists before another demand
Start with the work the customer accepted. Then list additions proposed during the job. Finally, list payments actually received, keeping reports awaiting confirmation separate. Do not combine the lists until you have checked each one.
For the accepted work, record the description, price basis, acceptance and any target dates. For additions, record what changed, the proposed cost, when it was sent and whether you can find acceptance. For payments, use the actual transaction date, amount and reference from your normal records.
Avoid filling blanks from habit. “We always charge £75 for that” does not show what this customer agreed. “They saw me doing it” does not establish the price discussion. Put a clear question mark next to missing evidence rather than silently treating it as confirmation.
A hypothetical kitchen job
Imagine a fitter agrees a fixed £1,400 installation. Two additions arise: a £120 trim change accepted in writing and £90 of boxing-in work discussed on site, with no price acceptance found. The customer has paid £500 before the shared agreement was created and later paid another £400, which the fitter has checked and confirmed.
The accepted £1,400 plus the accepted £120 addition gives £1,520 of documented agreed work. The £900 received leaves £620 against that total. The £90 item is a separate unresolved question, not a figure to hide inside £710 due.
This calculation is only as good as the records behind it. If the £120 proposal was never accepted, it belongs with the unresolved items. If the £400 was only reported and has not been located, the receipt check still needs doing. State the actual position rather than borrowing the tidy numbers from this example.
Write a reconciliation the customer can follow
Use plain labels that distinguish statuses:
| Item | Position to check |
|---|---|
| Installation | £1,400 fixed, accepted before starting |
| Trim change | £120, proposal and acceptance located |
| Boxing-in | £90 proposed charge, price agreement not located |
| Earlier payment | £500 recorded as paid before setup |
| Later receipt | £400 checked and confirmed received |
| Remaining on documented agreed work | £620 |
Keep copies of the underlying records. A table is an explanation, not a replacement for the original messages or receipts. If you send it to the customer, use the dates and references relevant to their job rather than writing “accepted” without showing what you mean.
Send a question about the gap
A useful message separates the clear calculation from the unresolved item:
“I've checked the job records. The original £1,400 installation and accepted £120 trim change total £1,520. We have received £900, leaving £620 against those items. I also listed £90 for boxing-in, but I haven't located a clear price agreement for it. Please tell me your understanding of that item so we can discuss it separately.”
This is more candid than “everything was agreed on site”. It also gives the customer a smaller, answerable question. They can correct the payment record, identify another acceptance message or explain why they thought the boxing-in was included.
Do not label the uncertain item a gift or declare that it is automatically owed. Those are conclusions the record does not establish. Keep the discussion factual and get appropriate advice if you need to determine the legal position.
What if the original scope was vague?
Perhaps the scope said “finish the kitchen” and the customer reasonably expected the boxing-in to be part of finishing. Re-read the actual language before insisting that the work is an extra. Your internal estimate may be more detailed than anything they received.
Ask what the customer understood and compare it with the description you sent. If the scope does not resolve the question, say that plainly. You can discuss a commercial resolution without inventing a history in which the price was explicit from the start.
For future jobs, name the likely boundary in the scope: for example, “fit the listed units; boxing around existing pipes is excluded and will be quoted if required”. Use a real boundary relevant to your trade. An exclusions list copied from another job can create a different misunderstanding.
Check the payment allocation
A transfer reference may point to the wrong invoice or cover more than one job. Ask the customer what a payment was intended to settle, then compare that with your accounting records. Do not move it silently between jobs to make a late invoice disappear.
For the hypothetical fitter, suppose the customer says the later £400 covered an unrelated repair. That changes the reconciliation. Find the corresponding invoice and discuss the allocation before sending another balance summary. Preserve the original transaction record and document any correction.
The same care applies to deposits. Money already paid at setup is a historical starting position in AsAgreed. Do not also count it as a new confirmed receipt. A starting £500 and a later £400 total £900, not £1,400 because the first amount appears twice in two places.
For your next quote, name the included work and likely exclusions before additions or payments complicate the picture.
Write the scope for your next quote
Use AsAgreed within its revision boundary
Before any new payment report or receipt, AsAgreed supports a proposed complete revised scope and price. The currently accepted version stays in place until the customer explicitly accepts the revision. A draft proposal does not change what is agreed.
Once a new payment report or receipt exists, further scope and price revisions are unavailable. Later extras need a fresh agreement. This matters for jobs that take an early payment: plan the record structure before the extra appears rather than expecting to keep enlarging a paid agreement.
A fresh agreement for a later extra should identify the new work clearly. It should not duplicate the entire original balance or make the customer think the old job has been cancelled. Keep the original job reference in your correspondence so the relationship between the records is understandable.
Treat a promised payment as a next action
After seeing the reconciliation, the customer may promise £300 on Friday. Record the discussion and ask when the remainder will be addressed. Do not report £300 as sent simply because there is now a plan.
If the customer sends it outside AsAgreed, they can report it. You confirm receipt after checking it arrived, and only then does the confirmed balance reduce. Reporting a partial payment does not schedule or collect the next one automatically.
A suitable acknowledgement is: “£300 received and confirmed against the installation balance. The remaining amount on those agreed items is £320. The boxing-in question remains separate and I'll respond to your message about it tomorrow.” That keeps both threads visible without mixing them.
If you agree a reduction
A concession or correction needs an accurate invoice or credit record in your normal accounting process. It is not a receipt. Do not enter fictitious money in AsAgreed to force a zero balance, and do not delete the original invoice correspondence to make the history look simpler.
Where the shared agreement cannot be revised because payment activity already exists, retain it as the historical record and explain the adjustment alongside your accounting documents. Make the relationship clear for the customer and anyone handling the books.
If the amount or dispute is material, get advice on the appropriate process. A clear chronology is useful preparation. It is not a substitute for advice about rights, tax treatment or recovery.
End with two next steps
Your final reconciliation should say what each person will do next. Perhaps you will locate an approval message by Thursday, and the customer will confirm the payment reference for £400. Avoid ending with a vague “please resolve urgently” when there are specific checks still outstanding.
Use a review date to return to the record. If facts change, send a corrected summary and explain the correction. Do not keep quoting an old balance after confirming a receipt or accepting an adjustment.
Put a review date on the calculation
A reconciliation is a snapshot. If you send it on Monday and confirm a payment on Tuesday, Monday's figure is no longer the current balance. Put the preparation date on your summary and recheck it before sending another message.
For the kitchen example, a later confirmed £200 would reduce the £620 on documented agreed work to £420. It would not decide the unresolved £90 item. Show both facts in the next summary instead of changing one combined total without explanation.
If more than one person maintains records, decide who updates the shared calculation and who corrects the accounting allocation. Keep the transaction reference with the check. Avoid duplicate entries when two colleagues see the same transfer. This is manual reconciliation across your own records, not automatic bank matching by AsAgreed. A dated, explainable calculation is more useful than a running total whose changes nobody can reconstruct.
Carry the lesson into the next quote
Ask where this job became hard to follow. Was the scope too broad? Were extras agreed across several channels? Was an earlier payment counted twice? Was the invoice sent before the final price was settled? Fix the relevant habit rather than adding more paperwork everywhere.
The tradespeople page shows scope, price and payments together. For your next quote, write the exclusions and change process while there is time to discuss them calmly.